What to Do When Your Content Isn’t Performing

6 min read
A laptop screen displaying financial charts and graphs during an analysis session

Six months into a content strategy, a client will sometimes ask us some version of “is this even working?” Fair question, and also, more often than not, the wrong one to start with. “Working” isn’t binary. Content underperforms for a handful of distinct reasons, and the fix for each one is completely different, which is exactly why “let’s just post more” so rarely helps, and occasionally makes the actual problem worse by burying it under more of the same mistake.

First, define what “not performing” means for you

No traffic, traffic with no inquiries, and inquiries from the wrong kind of client are three separate problems that get lumped into one complaint. Each needs its own diagnosis, the same distinction we draw in why traffic is nice but pipeline is better. Before touching a single post, get specific about which of the three you have, because the fix for one can make another one worse if you guess wrong.

If nobody’s finding it

This is usually a targeting problem, not a quality problem. Content answering questions nobody’s searching, or chasing a term too competitive for a newer site, will underperform no matter how well it’s written. The fix here isn’t better writing. It’s better research before the writing starts: pulling actual search volume and competition data on a topic before committing a full post to it, rather than guessing based on what feels important to the business.

If people find it but don’t convert

This is almost always a call-to-action or funnel problem, not a traffic problem, the same diagnosis we laid out when we looked at why a B2B website wasn’t converting the traffic it was already getting. More traffic won’t fix a page that never asks the visitor to do anything specific. If a post gets read all the way through and still doesn’t produce an inquiry, check what happens in the last two paragraphs before assuming the whole piece needs a rewrite. Often it’s one missing sentence, not one broken strategy.

If it’s converting the wrong people

The content is probably too broad, pulling in a mixed audience instead of the specific one you want. The fix here is sharper positioning language, not more volume, and definitely not fewer posts. A post trying to appeal to everyone in your general category ends up attracting a lot of people who were never going to be a good fit, and filtering them out earlier in the content saves everyone the wasted consultation.

The audit we run before touching anything

Pull impressions, clicks, and conversions separately. Find the handful of pages dragging the average down instead of judging the whole strategy by a blended number, since a strategy that looks flat overall is often five strong pages and five weak ones canceling each other out on the dashboard. The right metrics to watch are the same ones covered in the six numbers a law firm should be tracking, and the two to stop caring about. Once you know which specific pages are underperforming and why, the fix is usually narrow: a rewritten headline, a clearer call to action, a retargeted keyword, not a wholesale strategy reset.

When the real issue isn’t the content at all

Sometimes the content is doing its job and the breakdown happens after. A form that takes too long, a phone line nobody answers promptly, an inbox where inquiries sit for two days before a reply. We’ve seen clients fix targeting and calls to action, watch inquiries tick up, and then lose most of that gain because the follow-up process on the other end couldn’t keep pace. Before blaming the writing, walk through what happens after someone clicks the button you asked them to click.

What this diagnosis looked like for one client

A wellness brand client came to us convinced their entire content strategy had stopped working, because monthly traffic had been flat for a quarter. The audit told a different story. Traffic was flat because two older, high-performing posts had slipped out of ranking after a competitor published fresher content on the same topics, while everything else was holding steady or growing slightly. The fix wasn’t a new strategy. It was refreshing two specific posts with more current information, which is a one-week project, not a three-month overhaul.

How often to run this audit

Quarterly is usually the right cadence for a professional services content program. Monthly is too soon to see a real pattern in most industries, since normal traffic fluctuation can look like a trend when it’s really just noise. Waiting a full year, on the other hand, means a fixable problem gets to compound for months before anyone notices, which is its own kind of expensive. A quarterly check-in catches most issues while they’re still small and specific enough to fix in a week rather than a quarter.

What “healthy” looks like

For a professional services blog publishing consistently, a reasonable benchmark is steady or growing traffic quarter over quarter, at least one or two posts ranking on the first page for a targeted term within six to nine months, and a small but consistent trickle of inquiries that mention a specific piece of content. None of that sounds dramatic, and it shouldn’t. A content program that looks calm and steadily improving on paper is usually doing exactly what it’s supposed to do.

It’s worth saying plainly: a strategy hitting those benchmarks and still feeling disappointing is usually a mismatch between the numbers and the expectations set at the start, not a real performance problem. If leadership was told to expect a dramatic month-two turnaround and got steady, compounding growth instead, that’s a communication issue on the front end, not evidence the content isn’t working on the back end.

Before you scrap a content strategy, find out which of these problems you have. Most of the time it’s fixable in weeks, not a reason to start over.

FAQs

Q: How do I know if my content marketing strategy isn’t working? Separate the problem into stages: is content getting found (traffic), is it converting once found (inquiries), and are the right people converting (lead quality)? Each stage points to a different fix, and lumping them together usually leads to the wrong one.

Q: How long should I wait before deciding content marketing isn’t working? Give a new strategy at least three to six months before drawing conclusions, since organic content typically needs that long to start ranking and generating consistent traffic. Judging performance at 30 or 60 days usually produces a false negative.

Q: What’s the most common reason content isn’t converting? A missing or unclear call to action. Content that informs well but never gives the reader one specific next step trains people to read and move on rather than reach out.

Q: Should I stop publishing if my current content isn’t performing? Usually not. Pausing production rarely fixes the underlying issue and can slow the compounding effect that makes content work in the first place. Diagnosing and fixing the specific problem is almost always faster than starting over.

Picture of Kristin Abele

Kristin Abele

Kristin Abele is the co-founder and Creative Partner of TFG Marketing + Design, a boutique full-service marketing and design agency she co-founded in 2011. She specializes in content strategy, creative direction, brand voice, and omnichannel digital marketing strategy for small and midsize businesses across professional services industries. Over 15 years, her work has helped clients across 45+ industries achieve compounding growth from regional law firms to Fortune 500 corporations.

Want this kind of thinking on your marketing?

Book a free 30-minute consult. No pitch deck, just an honest read on what your marketing needs.

Finally. A newsletter worth subscribing to.

Marketing ideas you can use, from people who do this every day. No spam, and you can unsubscribe anytime.

Scroll to Top
Free · 3-Minute Scorecard

How's your marketing actually doing?

16 quick questions across brand, content, visibility, and strategy. Get a personalized score and see exactly where to focus next.

Take the Quiz
Takes about 3 minutes.